Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel

Consumers' Corner

April 2009

In this issue...

 

Guidelines strict for door-to-door solicitors

As Ohioans are presented with more opportunities to choose their natural gas suppliers, it is important to understand the rules that govern what marketers can and cannot do to get consumers’ business.

Increased competition in the natural gas marketplace is one way to keep bills low. When more suppliers are available for homeowners to choose from, the chances are better that lower rates will result.

However, consumers need to keep in mind that with the growing number of independent suppliers competing for new clients, chances are that Ohioans will receive a visit from a door-to-door salesperson. If consumers are visited by a solicitor, they should know that there are rules that must be followed when asking to switch natural gas suppliers.

Ohio law clearly defines the code of conduct that natural gas salespersons must follow. If consumers receive a visit from someone claiming to represent a marketer, he/she should make sure the salesperson has done the following:

  • Stated that he/she is a representative of the marketer and NOT the utility;

  • Fully explained any documents to be signed, how much it will cost, including tax, and how long the contract will be in effect; and

  • Orally explained the right to cancel and has given right-to-cancel forms.

All door-to-door salespeople must show valid photo identification issued by the natural gas supplier. Within three days of receiving a consumer’s signature, the marketer is required to notify the natural gas utility of his/her intention to switch companies.

The OCC is available to assist with questions about choosing a natural gas supplier. Call toll free, 1-800- PICKOCC (1-800-742-5622) or review the “Comparing Your Energy Choices” fact sheet on the OCC Web site, www.pickocc.org, for up-to-date information about current suppliers and their offers.

return to top ^

To save more money

Turn completely off the most costly electronic gadgets in your home

Household appliances and electronics contribute to a majority of the expenses seen on monthly electric bills. What consumers may not know is a significant portion of that expense could be a result of items that are not even used.

Computers, video game consoles, digital clocks, televisions, refrigerators and cell phones still use power even when they are “off.” This status is referred to as vampire or standby power. Items that use a remote control, have an external power supply like an AC adaptor, digital display, battery charger or soft-touch key pad are all examples of standby power products that have the effect of driving consumers’ electric bills up.

The amounts of power these items use when they are in standby mode can be startling. According to the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, a digital cable box with DVR capabilities uses more than 40 watts of electricity when it is turned off. While most devices use much less electricity while in standby, combined they can account for up to 10 percent of your monthly electricity bill.

Some standby power is necessary. Modern conveniences likely would not be as convenient without it. It enables monitoring of refrigerator temperatures, allows use of remote controls, keeps digital clocks running and charges cellular phones. But most standby power is wasteful because of inefficient AC adaptors.

Common household appliances can add up to several dollars per month even when they are off.
Product Average Watts – On Average Watts – Off
Desktop Computer 74 W 2.8 W / 21 W (sleep mode)
Notebook Computer 30 W (charged) 8.9 W / 15.8 W (sleep mode)
Digital cable box with DVR 44.4 W 43.5 W
PS3/Xbox 360/Wii 150W / 119W / 16W 1.1W / 3.1W / 1.9 W
Television - 32” CRT 162 W 2 W
Microwave 1,433 W 3 W
DVD Player 9.9 W 1.6 W
Cellular Phone 3.7 W (charging) 2.2 W (charged)
Cable Modem 6.3 W 3.8 W
CPU Monitor - LCD 27.6 W 1.1 W / 1.4 W (sleep mode)
Sources: ENERGY STAR, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Natural Resources Defense Council

While it may be impossible to eliminate standby power, there are several ways to reduce the amount that is used in a consumer’s home. To cut the amount of standby power used, unplug products that are not regularly used. Consumers can also attach several similar items, like computer equipment, to a power strip and turn it off while away. Items like cable boxes and Internet modems, which rely on standby power to send information, should be connected to a different circuit so the connection is not lost.

Consumers also can search for ENERGY STAR-rated products. These items use energy more efficiently and must meet specific requirements for standby power to earn an ENERGY STAR rating.


return to top ^

Alternatives available to traditional telephone service

Telephone service is an essential need for most Ohioans to stay connected with family and emergency services. With the cost of utility services, including telephone, continuing to climb, searching for alternative options may be one way for consumers to control their utility budgets.

For consumers who subscribe to a telephone including special services and some allowance for long distance calling, there are a number of alternatives to consider when looking for the best available price and services. Traditional landline carriers, competitive carriers such as cable companies and cell phone providers offer a variety of bundled packages as options. Phone service over a broadband connection also is a viable alternative, where available. When comparing choices, consumers should be sure to carefully compare prices and packages.

Consumers who subscribe only to basic telephone service have fewer alternatives, if any. Many competing companies do not offer basic service by itself. These companies only offer packages that include services not all customers want or need.

Cellular or wireless phone service has become a popular form of communication to stay in touch with family and friends. Cell phone providers offer many features and calling plans in specific areas using a set amount of minutes each month. Some companies also offer plans with unlimited calling. Cell phones allow consumers to stay connected whenever and wherever they want. But some areas still do not have a strong enough cell signal. Consumers should check with each cell phone company to determine whether that company’s coverage areas meet their needs. In addition, many wireless providers require a multi-year contract for service and there may be fees for early cancellation.

Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) is a telephone service that could provide savings over traditional landline service. A broadband Internet connection and special equipment is required to make and receive calls. It is possible that 9-1-1 service may be unavailable and VoIP service may be interrupted during a power outage.

There are advantages and risks to all of these telephone options. All traditional local and long-distance telephone companies must meet Ohio’s minimum telephone service standards. These regulations include how much time a company can take to restore service and what action can be taken by companies if a consumer’s bill is not paid on time.

Wireless service can give you the freedom to talk without needing a landline telephone and VoIP also may provide savings over traditional telephone service. These services are not regulated in Ohio and the minimum telephone service standards do not apply to the companies that provide them.

The Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel has more information about each of these telephone options on its Web site. Consumers also can compare the costs and options available at www.pickocc.org or by calling toll free 1-877-742-5622.


return to top ^

AEP rate plan approved by PUCO

The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) approved a modified electric security plan for American Electric Power’s (AEP) two operating companies March 18. The resulting plan will increase total bills for residential customers of Columbus Southern Power by no more than 7 percent in 2009 and 6 percent in both 2010 and 2011 while Ohio Power customers’ rates will increase by 8 percent in both 2009 and 2011 and by 7 percent in 2010.

After an initial analysis of AEP’s electric security plan, the Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel (OCC) has mixed feelings about the PUCO decision. While the 52 percent rate increase requested by AEP has been reduced significantly, it will be allowed to collect any costs that exceed its approved rate increase at a later date with interest. These extra costs would be collected from 2012-2018 at an interest rate of more than 10 percent. The OCC had argued for minimal rate increases that would have eliminated the need for deferred costs.

The OCC also is concerned that the PUCO has allowed AEP to collect these new rates from customers retroactive to January 2009. The OCC believes this is unlawful.

The approved plan also will require AEP to make improvements to reliability. The OCC believes this is a step in the right direction. The Counsel has advocated on behalf of customers for increased reliability for several years, but the decision only deals with part of the reliability problem. The electric security plan does allow AEP to begin smart grid infrastructure improvements and approved an enhanced vegetation management program that has proposed to place additional resources and increased vegetation management work along power lines.

Stay tuned to the next edition of Consumers’ Corner for a more detailed recap and the full impact the rate plan will have AEP customers. The OCC also will detail the approved electric security plans for Dayton Power & Light, Duke Energy Ohio and FirstEnergy residential customers.


return to top ^

Violation could cost Aqua Ohio thousands of dollars

Aqua Ohio could face fines of up to $10,000 per violation for failure to resolve billing issues that affect its residential customers. The Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel (OCC) represented residential customers in a hearing to determine if the company violated the law and the appropriate amount of penalty for those violations. Aqua Ohio already has conceded to some fault for the violations. The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio staff has recommended that its commissioners accept an October 2008 agreement that would require Aqua Ohio to pay a total of $25,000 to three separate community action agencies and be fined $1,000 per day until the billing issues are resolved.

The OCC has worked with Aqua Ohio over the past year to resolve the company’s billing and backlog issues. Throughout the course of two settlements, Aqua agreed to fix all these issues by Oct. 15, 2008. As of February, customers were still reporting billing issues to the OCC and PUCO. The billing problems have resulted in customers not receiving an actual meter reading or a bill for extended periods of time. Other customers complained about improperly assessed late payment fees.

The OCC filed testimony on behalf of residential consumers Feb. 17 regarding these problems. In addition to a $25,000 contribution the company agreed to pay to three community action agencies, the OCC also is requesting the PUCO order daily penalties for Aqua Ohio’s failure to resolve all billing issues by the Oct. 15 deadline and to take other necessary action to resolve these problems. A PUCO decision is anticipated in April.


return to top ^

Choice consumers urged to read fine print

While many Ohioans have their heating source delivered directly from a major natural gas company such as Columbia Gas of Ohio, Dominion East Ohio Gas, Duke Energy Ohio or Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, not all purchase gas from these companies. Some have elected to purchase natural gas from a competitive natural gas company to heat their home. Customers who make this choice must sign a contract with the supplier before receiving natural gas from them. It is the details entailed in the contract that consumers must understand fully before accepting an offer.

Falling natural gas prices and increased competition have given customers the freedom to comparison shop for lower rates but also has led to confusion among those who did not fully understand the details of the agreement they entered into. It is up to consumers to understand the fine print before signing any agreement. If consumers are unsure of anything in the language of an agreement, they should ask the marketer questions or refer to the company’s Web site.

Many sites include frequently asked questions to address commonly occurring situations. Questions that are not completely addressed by the question and answer pages should be directed to the company’s customer service center.

Consumers should have a complete understanding of the agreement before enrolling with a marketer.

Consumers should verify the following before completing an enrollment:

  • Whether the agreement will be automatically renewed upon completion;

  • Whether automatic renewal would be subject to a higher rate;

  • An understanding of whether the rate is a fixed or variable rate and what those two terms mean;

  • Whether any additional fees, such as for enrollment, transfer or cancellation, may be charged; and

  • That the supplier is a certified participant in Ohio’s choice programs.

After consumers have received their first bill, they should check the numbers against the signed copy of the contract to make sure the charges assessed reflect what was agreed to. Consumers need to be aware that in many cases, if they decide to switch to a different supplier offering a lower rate, it generally takes 45-60 days for the new rate to go into effect.

Consumers should be sure to read and save any materials received from the supplier as they may include notices of changes to the original offer, rate or length of the service agreement.

The Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel (OCC) offers an up-to-date chart listing of all alternative suppliers in Ohio, their rate offers with fixed or variable rate contracts and the contract length. The OCC’s “Comparing Your Energy Choices” chart is available at www.pickocc.org. Consumers also may contact the OCC toll free at 1-877-742-5266 with questions about natural gas choice.

Types of Natural Gas Contracts

Common choice contracts include:

Fixed Rate — A rate where the price per unit of gas stays the same. Agreements usually range from 6 months to 3 years;

Variable Rate — This rate can change over a period of time based on various conditions;

Percentage off GCR — This rate offers a discount off the natural gas company’s gas cost recovery rate; and

Hybrid programs — These offers often have different rates associated with season changes or start as a variable rates and then changes to a fixed rate.


return to top ^

Give the OCC your opinion

For decades, the Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel has communicated with consumers through its bi-monthly newsletter, Consumers’ Corner. This publication is available in both electronic and print versions. In order to measure its effectiveness, the OCC wants to hear what your opinions are of the newsletter.

You can provide your opinion in one of two ways:

1) Electronically – Visit www.pickocc.org and click on the Consumers’ Corner newsletter survey link on the front page.

2) By phone – You can call the OCC toll-free at 1-877-742-5622 and ask for the OCC Communications Department. A staff member will accept your responses.

Please spend a few minutes to answer 10 brief questions. All responses are anonymous.


return to top ^

Information believed accurate but not guaranteed.
For information about our privacy policy and copyright, visit our Legal Disclaimer page.
The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel is an equal opportunity employer and provider of services.
Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel - Your Residential Utility Consumer Advocate OCC Seal Home En Español Search Ask Utility Questions Action Alerts